Skip to Content
Home » Food Comparisons » Ranch Dressing vs Mayo Dressing: 8 Main Differences

Ranch Dressing vs Mayo Dressing: 8 Main Differences

You will come across endless varieties in the world of dressings and dips.

Ranch and Mayo or Mayonnaise come at the top of the dressing suggestions.

Among all dressings, mayo, and ranch share some similarities in terms of taste.

This makes many people think they can be used interchangeably.

If you share the same belief, you should read this blog.

We will give you in-depth knowledge about ranch and mayo differences.

You will know more about what makes each of them unique and irreplaceable.

Ranch Dressing vs. Mayo Dressing
The main differences between Ranch and Mayo are their ingredients, taste, texture, color, calorie count, nutritional value, origin, and uses. Both can be bright white, but mayo can come in cream and faded yellow.

What is Ranch Dressing?

The Ranch is one of the most popular dressings used in the U.S.

However, it is currently getting out of the U.S. borders to invade European and Asian cuisines.

The ranch is a highly preferred option for dressing different salads and pizzas.

This dressing has a bright white color and a rich taste.

Such richness comes from its various ingredients.

Making delicious ranch dressing requires buttermilk, mustard, mayonnaise, sour cream, and a mix of herbs.

Onions and garlic are added to the mix to increase their tanginess.

The creation of this creamy dressing was coincidental.

A plumber who liked to cook for his friends and coworkers created it in Alaska. 

One dinner after another, the dressing reached perfection and became famous.

Ranch dressing history dates back to the early 1950s.

Aside from using ranch dressing on salads, it also works well as a dipping sauce.

The presence of buttermilk and yogurt in ranch sauce makes it rich in probiotics.

This makes the dressing useful for the digestive system.

Various food companies in America manufacture the recipe for ranch dressing.

So this explains its widespread use all over North America.

What is Mayo Dressing?

Mayo or mayonnaise dressing is another famous sauce in American fast food.

It mainly consists of jarred or homemade mayonnaise, vinegar, and spices.

It is easy to get mayo dressing from any nearby supermarket.

It is inexpensive and makes various sandwiches and sides a tasty addition.

Despite its availability on the shelf, many people love homemade mayo dressing.

Making this dressing at home is relatively easy.

Mixing some egg yolk with vegetable oil, lemon juice, and vinegar is all it takes.

While mayo is delicious, it can be combined with other ingredients to create more sauces.

This includes making ranch and tartar sauces.

Mayo dressing is served and used cold.

When using this sauce, you are free to control its thickness.

You can add more vinegar to make it thinner, and vice versa.

People who do not like the presence of raw egg yolks or the idea of eggs do not have to avoid mayo anymore.

Some eggless varieties suit their tastes and choices.

Just like it varies in its consistency, mayo dressing varies in color.

It can range between bright white and faded yellow.

Most of the time, mayo is off-white or cream.

Differences between Ranch Dressing and Mayo Dressing

Ranch and mayo dressings can have some similarities in color and texture.

These similarities make many people confuse one for another and even replace them in some recipes.

Despite using mayo to create ranch dressing, the overall taste won’t be the same.

1. Ingredients

One of the fundamental differences between ranch and mayo dressings is their ingredients.

First of all, mayonnaise is made from fewer components.

Also, the fat component in both items is different.

Mayo has vegetable oil, while ranch has buttermilk.

2. Taste

When you try ranch and mayo dressings simultaneously, you will instantly notice their creaminess.

However, their tastes are way different.

Due to the variety of mayo brands, the taste is not stable.

But in general, mayo has some tanginess and saltiness.

Despite the presence of some types of mayo with a slight sweetness, it is generally considered tart.

On the other hand, ranch dressing has a prominent mayo flavor, but garlic and onions are apparent there too.

Also, the presence of buttermilk makes the sauce creamier and richer.

Generally, the increased components in ranch dressing give it a more pungent taste and a more diverse flavor.

3. Texture

You can find different mayo consistencies, but the most common types are generally thick.

Ideally, it should be thick, consistent, and lump-free.

Ranch, on the other hand, is always thin.

This is why it can be easily poured over any item.

4. Color

In this comparison, color can be very confusing.

You can find these two in white.

However, mayo can be available in different colors, whereas ranch is always white.

You can find mayo in off-white, cream, or faded yellow.

5. Calorie count

Ranch and mayo dressings are high in calories.

Still, mayo has more calories. 

Every 100 grams of mayo can give you around 700 calories.

The exact amount of ranch dressing gives you about 450 calories.

6. Nutritional value

As you already know, both items are used in various fast food dishes.

So, they are not considered nutritious.

Ranch dressing contains yogurt and cultured buttermilk.

This makes ranch a healthier option for the digestive system.

Ranch dressing contains industrial sugar and refined carbohydrates.

This makes it bad for people with unstable blood sugar.

Mayonnaise, on the other hand, has almost no carbs but is high in fat.

This is usually dangerous for people who have unstable blood pressure.

7. Uses

Despite some apparent similarities, ranch, and mayo dressings are not substitutes for each other.

For instance, you can use ranch as a topping for pizza, whereas it is not an option to do the same with mayo.

Also, you can use mayo as a dressing for burgers, while it is not always acceptable to match ranch with burgers.

Also, you can use mayo to create various other sauces, including ranch.

However, it is impossible to include a ranch in another sauce recipe. 

One of the few times you can substitute ranch for mayo is when you enjoy fries or similar fried items.

You can create delicious dips out of these two delectable dressings.

8. Origin

Ranch dressing is an all-American sauce that was created in Alaska.

A cooking enthusiast and plumber invented this sauce while cooking for friends.

This happened in 1949.

Mayo, on the other hand, was developed in France.

A French chef created the recipe in 1756.

So, mayo is much older than ranch.

Ranch Dressing vs Mayo Dressing: are they the same?

No, Ranch and Mayo are not the same types of dressing.

The ranch is primarily made of mayo with other ingredients like garlic, onions, buttermilk, and yogurt.

Also, spices and herbs are included in the recipe.

Mayo contains egg yolk, vinegar, lemon juice, and oil.

Ranch and mayo are from different countries, separated by centuries.

The difference in their ingredients makes ranch and mayo taste differently.

Both are tangy, but some mayo varieties have a slight sweetness. 

Ranch, on the other hand, has more substantial and diverse flavors.

Mayo is higher in fat and calories, while ranch is higher in refined sugars.

Lastly, the ranch is commonly used over pizza, while the ranch is used on burgers.

Do you like this recipe or these cooking tips?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

(Visited 258 times, 3 visits today) Protection Status