How To Reheat Little Caesars Pizza – The 4 Best Ways

We all love and enjoy Little Caesars pizza, whether it be stuff crust, deep dish, or ultimate supreme. It is certainly one of the best choices you can make when it comes to pizza.

In case you got ahead of yourself (it happens even to the best of us) and overestimated your hunger by ordering one too many pizzas, don’t worry – it won’t go to waste.

What is the best way to reheat Little Caesars pizza? If you reheat your pizza in an oven, your guests will think it has just been delivered to your door. With our tricks, you can get similar results using a toaster oven, microwave, or pan.

The best ways to reheat Little Caesars pizza

Little Caesars pizza is one of the absolute leaders in the industry, due to the high quality of products and an unmatched dough recipe. There’s also a great variety of crusts, pizza toppings, and topping combinations you may not be able to try on other pizzas.

While Little Caesars will still taste incredible the next morning, what happens if you can’t finish it by then? The only two options you have are to store your leftovers in the fridge, or to freeze pizza for future use (which is actually a very convenient method).

Having Little Caesars pizza in your freezer is a great hack when your friends come over, and you want to prepare something quickly. All you need to do is let the pizza defrost at room temperature, and then use one of our methods to reheat it.

One of the biggest concerns people have is whether a reheated pizza will taste nearly as good as the real deal. The secret is in storing your pizza before it becomes stale, and then reheating it properly, without overcooking it.

It is also possible to reheat stale pizza, especially if you decide to use the oven, and add a couple of drops of oil to retain the moisture. We also recommend adding a handful of cheese on top of your pizza before reheating it to bring back all the flavors.

When storing your pizza, it is important not to just leave it in the box it came with and shove it into the fridge. Instead, you want to take it out of the box, place it onto a plate, and wrap it with a piece of foil, parchment paper, or freezer paper.

If you have more leftover pieces, you want to stack them on a plate and wrap them tightly, so that no air is left between the pieces. This will ensure that your pizza doesn’t dry out and become hard and flavorless.

When freezing your pizza, you want to repeat the stacking process, but in a large freezer bag. Ensure that there is no air in the bag and that it is closed tightly, before placing it into the freezer. 

You can keep the pizza in the fridge for about 3-4 days, while it is best to use up your frozen pizza within 2 months. Needless to say, after defrosting your pizza, you want to check for any signs of spoilage (color changes, mold, weird smell) before reheating it.

Now that you know how to properly store your pizza, let’s see how to bring it back to life.

How to reheat Little Caesars pizza in the oven

This is certainly the best way to reheat Little Caesars pizza, especially if you’re heating up a frozen pizza. What you want to do is take the pizza out of the freezer at least an hour before, and let it defrost at room temperature completely.

The downside of using an oven is that it takes more time to preheat than other appliances, and it will leave your kitchen super hot. Also, it isn’t the best choice if you have only a couple of slices of pizza, but it is very convenient for large pizzas.

Nevertheless, reheating your pizza in the oven will leave it crispy, delicious, and fresh – as if it has just been delivered straight from Little Caesars. Also, make sure to add some more cheese on top for an even tastier experience.

Here are the steps to reheat Little Caesars pizza in oven:

  1. Preheat the oven to 350 °F.
  2. Preheat the oven pan for a couple of minutes in the oven.
  3. Take the pan out of the oven with protective gloves and place the pizza on it.
  4. You can also put the pizza on a piece of aluminum foil, and place it directly onto the oven rack.
  5. Heat up the pizza for 10 minutes, or leave it a bit longer to get a crispier crust.

How to reheat Little Caesars pizza in a toaster oven

Here’s a much more convenient solution if you only want to reheat a few slices or even a single slice of Little Caesars pizza. When you think about it, it is too much of a hassle to heat up your big oven for a single slice of pizza, isn’t it?

A toaster oven will give you the same results as the oven since they work on a similar principle. On the plus side, your kitchen won’t become unbearably hot, so using a toaster oven is a great option in the summertime. 

With a toaster oven, you can also place the pizza directly onto the rack, or preheat the oven pan and add the pizza. 

Here are the steps to reheat Little Caesars pizza in a toaster oven:

  1. Preheat your toaster oven to 350 °F (especially if you enjoy a crispier crust and bottom).
  2. Allow the oven pan to heat up in the oven before placing the pizza on it.
  3. You can also put the pizza on a piece of aluminum foil and place it on the rack.
  4. Reheat the pizza for about 10 minutes, or until the cheese has melted and the crust is crispy enough.

How to reheat Little Caesars pizza in the microwave

When it comes to reheating any type of dough in the microwave, there are mixed feelings and different experiences. While some people swear by their microwave for reheating their food, others avoid using it – especially when it comes to dough.

We certainly recommend other methods, especially to reheat frozen Little Caesars pizza, since the dough can often become too soft or soggy, or too hard and dry. 

If you use a high setting, you run the risk of your pizza getting burned and rock-hard, while reheating it on a low setting for a longer period of time may leave it dry, flavorless, soggy, and pretty much inedible. Follow our instructions to reheat Little Caesars pizza without drying it out

Here are the steps to reheat Little Caesars pizza in the microwave:

  1. Place the pizza slice(s) onto a microwave-safe plate.
  2. Place a microwave-safe cup or mug filled with water next to the plate with pizza to preserve the moisture, prevent the pizza from drying out, and allow for a more even and thorough cooking.
  3. Heat it up on high for no longer than 30-45 seconds, as it can get really dry and hard if you overcook it.
  4. Remove from the microwave and brush with some oil or melted butter if the crust seems too dry.

How to reheat Little Caesars pizza on the stovetop

Reheating your pizza in a pan may seem a bit counterintuitive since that’s not how you bake pizza in the first place. Also, you may be afraid that only the bottom of the pizza slice will get heated up since it makes no sense to flip it and ruin the toppings.

You’re right, it makes no sense to flip the slice and have all the cheese melt onto the pan and quite possibly burn. Instead, we’re going to use hot air to heat up the entire slice evenly, while getting that beautiful crust on the bottom. 

Here are the steps to reheat Little Caesars pizza on the stovetop:

  1. Put your pan (preferably a skillet) over medium-high heat.
  2. Place the pizza slice(s) into the pan, and let it heat up for a few minutes, without the lid.
  3. Add a few drops of water on the side of the pan – not the pizza slices.
  4. Put the lid on right away and let the steam heat up the rest of the pizza.
  5. Remove the pizza from the pan once the cheese has melted.

Can you reheat Little Caesars Pizza?

Yes, you can even reheat Little Caesars deep dish pizza, or any other kind of pizza from their menu, using one of our handy four methods. 

Use the oven to reheat the entire pizza or more pizzas, since it is spacious and strong enough to reheat your pizza evenly and thoroughly. You will get similar results with a toaster oven which you can use for small quantities. 

Using a microwave to reheat Little Caesars pizza is the last option we’d resort to since you run the risk of your pizza becoming either too soggy or too dry. However, as long as you follow our instructions, there shouldn’t be any unpleasant surprises.

Although it may seem surprising, one of your best options would be reheating pizza in a pan, since it allows you to get that beautiful crust on the bottom of the slice without drying out the toppings. It is also the most convenient option if you’re only reheating a slice or two.

error: Content is protected !!