How To Reheat Subway – The 5 Best Ways

With more than 40,000 locations around the globe, there’s a good chance that if you’re looking for something to eat, you’ll end up ordering Subway.

In fact, one can’t get enough of those rich and tasty Subway sandwiches, but what can you do when you end up with leftovers?

It’s possible to reheat Subway, as long as you know some tricks. By following our guide on how to reheat Subway, you’ll know exactly what to do with your leftover sandwich!

What is the best way to reheat Subway?

The best way to reheat Subway is to use an oven or a toaster oven, but you could also use an air fryer or a microwave if you’re in a hurry, or a pan if you don’t have any other choice.

The Best Ways To Reheat Subway

When it comes to reheating Subway, your goal is to get the sandwich hot enough to melt any cheese and warm up any ingredients that should be warmed up, but not hot enough to end up with too mushy or too crunchy bread.

The first thing you need to do is wrap the Subway sandwich in the paper it came in or in some new aluminum foil, to help preserve its freshness.

You could also use an airtight container, just remember that you should only leave the sandwich in the refrigerator for a few days because after that some toppings could begin to develop bacteria.

If you want to store your Subway sandwiches for more time, you could always freeze them.

Place them in a self-sealing bag and squish out as much air as you can before sealing them.

Eat frozen Subway sandwiches within 1 to 3 months, so that they’ll still have the best flavor and texture.

There are a few different methods to reheat a Subway sandwich, and choosing one depends mostly on your needs and what you have at hand.

Keep in mind that when choosing a method, you should also pay close attention to the ingredients of your Subway sandwich.

There are a few tips that can help you reheat different kinds of sandwiches, and you’re going to want to use one method if you want to reheat Subway meatball, and a different one to reheat Subway steak and cheese.

If this seems complicated, fear not: we have prepared a handy guide to help you choose the best method to reheat Subway sandwiches.

How to reheat Subway in an oven

If you’re looking for a fool-proof method to reheat your leftovers, the best thing you can do is to reheat a Subway sandwich in the oven.

Using an oven is an amazing way to achieve the perfect crunch factor in your bread, but you should keep in mind that there are a few ingredients that shouldn’t be reheated at high temperatures.

If your Subway sandwich has sauces like mayonnaise, for example, the oven is not the best way to go.

What you can do is try and remove the ingredients that shouldn’t be reheated at high temperatures, but if you can’t do that, simply choose a different method.

A great tip is to place the sandwich on a sheet pan so that it has an even surface while it reheats.

This will help you achieve the perfect consistency and texture. Also, if you have a lot of vegetables in your Subway sandwich, you might want to cut the reheating time by about half.

Here are the steps to reheat Subway in the oven:

1. Preheat your oven to 350°F degrees.
2. Place the sandwich on a sheet pan.
3. Reheat for 10 minutes (or 5 minutes if the Subway sandwich has a lot of vegetables.)
4. Check to see if the sandwich is warm enough.
5. If not, reheat for 2 more minutes.
6. Remove and serve.

How to reheat Subway in a toaster oven

Another method similar to the first one is to reheat Subway in a toaster oven.

This works pretty much the same as with a regular oven, but since it provides a more even reheating it can really be an amazing choice.

You could also choose to reheat frozen Subway in a toaster oven.

It’s faster than using a regular oven since the air circulates better and heats food quickly, but it also provides gentler heating, which is fundamental for ingredients like meat and sauces.

To avoid ending up with dry Subway sandwiches, cover them with aluminum foil, aim for a low-temperature setting, and check on your food every once in a while.

Remember that you should always double-check on your food, to ensure that you’re not reheating your Subway sandwich too much.

Here are the steps to reheat Subway in a toaster oven:

1. Preheat the toaster oven to 350°F degrees.
2. Place Subway sandwich on baking sheet.
3. Cover it with aluminum foil.
4. Heat on one side for 5 minutes.
5. Flip it and heat the other side for 5 more minutes.
6. Take out and enjoy.

How to reheat Subway in a microwave

If you need to reheat your Subway sandwich quickly and easily, you can always choose to reheat Subway in the microwave.

The microwave isn’t the best method to reheat Subway sandwiches, as leaving the sandwich in the microwave for too long can make the bread tough and the vegetables soggy, just like it happens with fried food, but if you’re in a hurry just follow the next few tips and you’ll be okay.

The first tip is to wrap a paper towel around your Subway sandwich to prevent it from getting soggy: this is especially useful if you’re reheating a frozen Subway sandwich because the paper towel will trap all the melting ice crystals.

The second tip is to microwave the Subway sandwich in short intervals so that you can constantly make sure that your sandwich is reheating nicely and not overcooking by accident.

Here are the steps to reheat Subway sandwich in a microwave:

1. Choose a microwave-safe dish.
2. Wrap a paper towel around your Subway sandwich.
3. Microwave the sandwich for 80 seconds.
4. Check on your food.
5. If reheated, serve and enjoy.
6. If not, microwave again for 20 seconds and keep checking.

How to reheat Subway in an air fryer

If you want a quick and easy method, but you don’t trust the microwave, you can always choose to reheat a Subway sandwich in an air fryer.

The best thing about using an air fryer to reheat leftover Subway is that it’s incredibly quick.

But it doesn’t compromise the quality of flavors and the texture of your sandwich.

You’ll have a perfectly reheated sandwich with crispy bread in no time.

Here’s a really great tip you should follow:

Remove the top of the Subway sandwich, reheat the sandwich without the top, and then add it for the last 30 seconds of cook time.

This will ensure the bread on top won’t accidentally come out very dry and burnt.

Always remember to check the temperature during the reheating process:

Put a butter knife or a cocktail stick through the central point of the sandwich, and if it comes out hot, your Subway sandwich is ready to be served.

Here are the steps to reheat Subway in an air fryer:

1. Load leftover Subway sandwiches into the basket.
2. Remove the top part.
3. Cook on medium heat for a few minutes.
4. Check the temperature with a butter knife.
5. Add the top part of the sandwich in the last 30 seconds of reheating time.
6. Remove and serve.

How to reheat Subway on the stove

If you don’t like any of the methods we’ve already talked about, you can always choose to reheat Subway sandwiches on the stove.

This is a perfect option for a sandwich that hasn’t been in the fridge yet, but it works pretty well on cold Subway sandwiches, too.

A key tip to make this method work:

Place the Subway sandwich in its paper or foil bag directly on the pan.

This way you won’t dirty your pan and, leaving the bag open, you’ll allow steam to escape and this will result in a perfectly reheated sandwich.

This can also help you check the crispy level of your Subway by putting a finger in the bag and touching the bread.

If it’s not crispy enough, you can flip on the other side a few times.

Here are the steps to reheat Subway on the stove:

1. Choose a skillet and use some non-stick spray.
2. Keep your Subway sandwich in its bag.
3. Cook for 30 to 45 seconds.
4. Flip and cook for 30 to 45 seconds more.
5. Check the crispiness of the bread.
6. If ready, remove and serve.
7. If not, flip again and reheat for 45 seconds more.

Can you reheat Subway?

Yes, you can reheat Subway, and as a matter of fact, there are multiple methods that allow you to enjoy a perfectly reheated Subway sandwich whenever you want.

Try to keep your Subway sandwiches in the best conditions possible, and to leave them in the refrigerator for just a few days.

If you want to store them for more time, place them in the freezer for up to 3 months.

Choosing the right approach depends mostly on your needs, but if you want to achieve the best possible outcome, you should reheat your Subway leftovers in the oven.

Reheating Subway in the oven allows you to get the perfect taste and the perfect texture for your sandwiches, but a toaster oven can be a great substitute.

The quickest and simplest way is to use a microwave, but you should consider that this definitely won’t get you the best results:

Subway sandwiches in the microwave tend to become soggy if you don’t know how to reheat them.

If you’re looking for a quick and simple method, though, you should consider using an air fryer.

This method is incredibly easy and yet can help achieve the perfect taste and consistency for your reheated Subway sandwiches.

If none of these methods work for you, you can always just decide to reheat your Subway leftovers on the stove.

Choosing the right skillet and remembering to check for the level of crispiness of the bread.

Next time you have some Subway leftovers make sure to follow our step-by-step guide and choose the method that works best for you:.

In just a few minutes, you’ll have perfectly good Subway sandwiches!